After saying Qul, attention is focused on Huwa with
full concentration, otherwise even without the use of the word
Huwa, the sense and sentence could have been complete, by just
saying Allahu Ahad.
Grammatically it is personal
pronoun of third person, singular, masculine. He refers to
God, as in many verses it (Huwa) has been used in place of
Allah. It means He is. It occurs in the Quran in this sense,
e.g:
Laailaaha Illaa Huwa (Illallaahu)
(2-255)
There is no god, but He
'Allahu laa ilaaha illaa Huwa' (3-1): 'Allah,
there is no god, but He. This sentence is called nafii wal
isbaat. nafii: negation, denial; that which is rejected is
nafii: e.g., 'there is no god'. wa: and isbaat: affirmation;
that which is affirmed is isbaat: e.g, 'but He'. The word Huwa
is often referred by Sufis as Huu, e.g: Laa ya'lamu maa Huwa
illaa Huu (Huwa): He, Whom no one knows what He Himself is,
but Himself. The use of the word Huwa, dissociates His Being
as separate and distinguished from all, anyone, and
everything. "..I (Allah) Am the Lord, the First, and the Last;
I am He." (Isaiah 41-4) From discussion, in the
preceding pages, on conjecture about God, different concepts
about theology, and theories about religion, we have observed
that it is not possible for man to fully understand and
correctly define His Nature and His Attributes. The style of
expression of Surah Ikhlaas also brings into light important
aspects of limitations of understanding and expression of man,
in this regard. We may note that Allah's Nature is so Sublime,
so far beyond our limited conception and imagination, that the
best way in which we may try to understand Him is as Allah has
introduced Himself in the Quran, and as His Prophet (Peace be
upon him) has himself explained. Within these limitations and
basic information provided by God Himself, many philosophical
approaches and scientific data, progressively becoming
available, are increasingly providing evidence that there is
One Creator-Designer-Fashioner-Provider-Organiser, Who is
directing, ruling, developing, evolving and managing all
worlds-creations with Mercy and Benevolence. Such a
marvelously coherent and comprehensive system is otherwise
unconceivable to come into existence and continue to remain in
operation in harmony. Therefore He must be Living and
Intelligent:
He personally manages and monitors His
affairs (32-5).
Also consider following: Allah
arranged for Moses (Peace be upon him) to be brought under His
observation: "In order that you (O Moses) may be brought up
under Mine Eye." 20-39 Allah kept Noah's Ark under His
observation: "Floating (Noah's Ark) under Our Eyes" 54-14
Narrated Abu Musa (may Allah be pleased with him): "We
were with the Prophet (Peace be upon him) on a journey, and
whenever we ascended a high place, we used to say, Allahu
Akbar. The Prophet (Peace be upon him) said: 'Don't trouble
yourselves too much! You are not calling a deaf or an absent
person, but you are calling One Who Hears, Sees
and is very near." (Bukhari, 484, Vol-IX) He is Independent of
all effects of His own creation, e.g., matter, space and time,
which are ever changing coordinates of physical system.
"He (Allah) is the Creator, the Inventor, the Bestower
of forms." 59-24 Narrated Ibn Abbas: "The Prophet (Peace be
upon him) used to invoke Allah at night saying: 'O Allah! All
the praises are for You. You are the Lord of the heavens and
the earth. All the Praises are for You. You are the Maintainer
of the heaven and the earth, and whatever is in them. All the
Praises are for You. You are the Light of the heavens and the
earth. Your Word is the Truth, and Your Promise is the Truth,
and the Meeting with You is the Truth, and the Paradise is the
Truth, and (Hell) Fire is the Truth, and the Hour is the
Truth. O Allah! I surrender myself to You, and I believe in
You, and I depend upon You, and I repent to You, and with You,
I stand against my opponents, and to You, I leave the
judgement. O Allah! Forgive me my sins that I did in the past,
or will do in the future, and also the sins I did in secret or
in public. You are my only God, and there is no other god for
me." (Bukhari, 482, Vol-IX)
Non-personified and
Non-abstract Personality
This
makes us realize that He is a Personality, Whom this Surah
introduces as Huwa (He), and not a mere abstract conception or
conjecture. Here Huwa is not used for pointation (ism
ishaaraa) towards something, but for introducing the
Personality in His Own Highness, Right, Reality, Standing and
Stature. Practices of many schools of tasawwuf (generally
mis-translated as mysticism, which has different nuances,
usages and expressions, in the West, e.g. mystic, mysticism,
mystical experience, mystical consciousness, etc.) can be
considered as attempts towards understanding of and contact
with the Being or Personality, called Huwa. But some of them
go so far after ineffable, in hazy hallucinations, that they
miss the Truth in mystic mist. They mix up imagination with
the Reality without realizing one's own limitations to contain
or to see within their finite physical frame the Infinite
Personality.
Narrated Masruuq: "Aisha (may Allah be
pleased with her) said: 'If an anyone tells you that Muhammad
(Peace be upon him) has seen his Lord, he is a liar, for Allah
says:
'No vision can grasp Him' 6-103 And
if anyone tells you that Muhammad (Peace be upon him) has seen
the unseen, he is a liar, for Allah says: 'None has the
knowledge of the unseen-hidden but Allah."
See
72-26 also. It is only after resurrection, when physical laws
will be changed, and man will be raised in such a form and
frame that he will be able to see his Lord (Allah): Narrated
Jarir bin Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him): The
Prophet (Peace be upon him) said: "You will definitely see
your Lord with your own eyes." (Bukhari, 530, Vol-IX)
"On the Day when the earth will be changed to another
(different) earth, and so will be the heavens, and they
(humanbeings) will appear before Allah , the One ,the
Irresistible." 14-48 Also see 50-22
Mysticism in
the West
"The word mystic
has its origin in the Greek mysteries. A mystic was one who
had been initiated into these mysteries, through which he had
gained an esoteric knowledge of divine things and been
reborn into eternity. His object was to break through
the world of history and time into that of eternity and
timelessness. The method was through initiation
ceremonies of the sort so vividly described by the late Latin
writer, Apuleius, in The Golden Ass. Through the mysteries the
initiated entered into something holy and numinous, a secret
wisdom about which it was unlawful for him to speak. The word
mystery (mysterion) comes from the Greek verb muo, to shut or
close the lips or eyes." (F.C.Happold, Mysticism, A Study and
an Anthology, p.18)
Examine above statement in the light of following verse
which highlights basic human weakness or desire to break
through physical existence, become super human, live for ever,
etc.:
"Then began Satan to whisper suggestions to them
(Adam and Eve), in order to reveal to them their shame, that
was hidden from them. He said: 'Your Lord only forbade you
this tree, lest you should become angels, or such beings as
live for ever." 7-20
Alongwith principles for
righteous-living, the Quran elevates righteous-dying to the
status of immortality: "Think not of those who are slain in
Allah's way as dead. Nay, they live finding their sustenance
in the Presence of their Lord. (169) "They rejoice in the
Bounty provided by Allah. And with regard to those left
behind, who have not yet joined them, the martyrs glory in the
fact that on them is no fear, nor they grieve. (170) "They
glory in the Grace and the Bounty from Allah and in the fact
that Allah sufers not the reward of the faithful to be lost."
(171) 3-169 to 171 , Also see 2.154
Usually masses get
misled by claims shrouded in secrecy that what the mystic sees
others don't, and that they are supposed not to disclose
details about it. It may be true in case of some individual
experience but at larger scales of a society, it can not be
generalized and prescribed for greater good of all. On the
other hand, Islam prescribes a straight path that develops
personality for the benefit of individual himself and the
society as a whole. The Quran enunciates principles of right
conduct on the Right Path for good of mankind, without
deviation. On the basis of this principle it explains that
salvation and success of individuals and nations are results
of devotion to God and righteous living. Failure
is the consequence of deviation from and disbelief in the
Truth (the immutable Law), i.e., salvation and condemnation,
here and Here-after, are determined by the immutable laws.
In the eastern tradition, tasawwuf implies closeness
and communion with God without any intermediary or intercessor
or interconnector and contradicts the idea of any curtain in
between. In this sense nearness or communion is not just
mystic as in the Western concept and in the sense of being
wholly ineffable or unclear
The Quran presents a clear
course to bring the slave nearer than the nearest to his
Lord-Master-Owner Allah, in communion:
"And when My
(Allah's) slaves ask you concerning Me, then I am indeed
close. I grant the prayer of the suppliant when he calls on
Me. So let them bear My call and let them trust in Me, in
order that they may be led aright". 2-186
In above
verse, comparative or superlative of the word `Qareeb' (Close)
has not been used which makes it absolute that it can't be
more close! "For, We (Allah) are nearer to him than (his)
jugular vein." 50-16 "And know that Allah comes in between a
man and his heart , and that it is He to Whom you shall be
gathered." 8-24
Consider implications involved for people in secret claims
in the light of following : "(Moses) said: 'What then is your
case O Saamri?' (95) "He replied:
'I saw what
they saw not, so I took a handful (of dust) from the
footprint of the Messenger, and threw it (into the calf). Thus
did my soul suggest to me." (96) 20-95 & 96
The
problem with such personal secretive claims is that they are
not verifiable. They are ineffable and inexplicable. They can
not be generalized and repeated for general and greater good;
even for one's own self they may not be available again.
Structures and institutions are essential for raising edifice
of a society, which require active participation of
individuals and groups excelling in knowledge and skill. The
Quran holds out guidance to the conscious (e.g., 2-2), and
promises wisdom-power (hikmah: e.g., 2-231 & 269). It is
guaranteed that effort of no one is let lost (3-195). In
addition God promises succour and success from His side
(3-160).
F.C. who has discussed mysticism and its
different aspects quite at length, defines characteristics of
mystical states, thus: ineffable, unintelligible, noetic,
transience, passivity, etc, etc. ((F.C.Happold, Mysticism, A
Study and an Anthology, pp. 45-46)
That is why when
process of general degradation set in the Ummah, the very
positive and useful institutions of Suufiis came to be mostly
misused for exploitation of poor and ignorant masses.
Therefore this can not be prescribed as a general norm. On the
contrary Islam prescribes active development of consciousness
for coming closer to God and pleasing Him with righteous
living.
Some people make an extra effort to present
mysticism as purely and wholly an Islamic principle, without
going into its contrast with Tasawwuf and history of the
former at least from Plato in the West, and from Chanakya in
the Sub-continent, when muslims came in contact with their
respective civilizations. They have even established different
brands and branches in the names of the Companions (may Allah
be pleased with them) and their followers separately.
Happold elaborates his point that all religions have
mystical expressions: "Any worth-while study of mysticism
must, however, of its nature, be a study of comparative
religion, for mysticism is a manifestation of something which
is at the root of all religion and all the higher religions
have their mystical expressions. I have not, therefore,
confined myself, either in the Study or in the Anthology, to
the expressions of mysticism within Christianity."
Interaction of different civilizations over a period
of time, and internal schism have developed different variants
of 'mysticism' within different religious communities and
groups as admixtures of inter-cultural influences, and even
heretic and secular encroachments.
"The word mysticism
is not a fully satisfactory one. The word is, however, used
with a number of different meanings and carries different
connotations to different minds. To some it is simply a type
of confused, irrational thinking. In the popular mind it is
associated with spiritualism and clairvoyance, with hypnotism,
and even with occultism and magic, with obscure psychological
states and happenings, some of which are the result of
neurasthenia and other morbid pathological conditions. To some
it is bound up with visions and revelations. Others use it as
a synonym for other-wordliness, or to describe a nebulous
outlook upon the world or a religious attitude, which does not
care for dogma or the outward forms of religious observance.
Some would limit its use to that rare state of consciousness
which is found in the contemplative saints." (F.C.Happold,
Mysticism, A Study and an Anthology, pp.16 &.36)
Mysticism is considered manifestation of something,
usually termed as truth, for which different religions use
different mystical expressions. In higher religions it is a
spiritual quest for the most direct experience of God. In
Christianity it is centered on prayer. God is considered
accessible through Scripture, Sacraments, and above all Jesus
Christ. Mystic seeks to go beyond concepts and images
presented in Scripture, theology, and tradition, and
comes to God himself. Theologians disagree on
mystic's claim about attainment of God, as to whether it is an
'experience', ever truly direct and immediate, or whether it
always involves mediation of concepts and ideas, or whether it
is mere imagination and visualization.
Mystics
symbolize attainment of God in different ways: St Bernard, St
Teresa, and St John of the Cross used images of sexual love
and spiritual marriage.
St Gregory Palamas speaks of
illumination by seeing uncreated light in transfiguration of
Jesus on Mount Tabor.
St Gregory of Nyssa sees the
mystic taken from revelation of God in light to the
unknowledge of him in darkness, as Moses (Peace be upon him)
met God first in the burning bush, and then in the cloud. On
the contrary the Quran tells that God is the Light of the
heavens and the earth: 24-35, and that He takes man from
darkness unto light:
"He it is (Allah) Who sends
blessings on you, as do His angels, that He may bring you out
from the depths of darkness into the Light. And He is full of
Mercy to the believers." 33-43.
Some other religions
also believe in this: "To show them special Mercy, I, dwelling
in their hearts, destroy with the shinning lamp of knowledge,
the darkness born of ignorance." (The Opulence of the
Absolute, Bhagavad-Gita as it is, p.366)
Like other religions, Christian mysticism also has many
forms, e.g:
i. Liturgical and sacramental mysticism,
as means of ascent to God, ii. Devotional mysticism
centered on meditation on the person, life, and teaching of
Jesus (Peace be upon him). iii. Contemplation, taking
different forms in eastern hesychasm and in western
philosophy, iv. Different schools of mysticism, using
discursive meditation as a means of preparation in the earlier
stages of the path, and then moving to contemplative prayer.
(J.R.Hinnells, Dictionary of Religions, pp.224-225)
As
in many other religions, Jews and Christians went too far in
personification of the Personality, that they sculptured Him
into dimensions, design and behaviour of physical creation.
But this very one word Huwa in Surah Ikhlaas is so iconoclast
in lexico-philological explanations that it demolishes all
iconization, sculpture and idolization. Furthermore, it is not
localized in a direction. Huwa (He) is all around, everywhere,
Necessary for all contingent existence and even for occurrence
of any idea or thought:
"..And know that Allah comes
in between man and his heart.." 8-24
Sufism
and Islam
In Islamic context,
Sufism developed its own institutions. Sufis and dervishes
congregated in houses or convents, variously called ribats,
khaankaahs, and zawiyas, foci for living communally, for
performing Jihaad against unbelievers, and as centres for
education and evangelism among un-islamic or imperfectly
Islamic people. These were charitable foundations (Waqf).
Within Sufi circles, a special liturgical ritual (dhikr,
literally remembrance of God) was practiced, including
repeated chanting of the Most Beautiful Best Names of God,
with or without a rosary, controlled breathing, dancing,
specially by Mevlevis, with music, etc. "In certain frontier
regions like Anatolia, the practices of some orders, e.g., the
Bektashis, showed a distinct syncretism with Christian
practices." (John R. Hinnells, Dictionary of Religions, p.313)
Suufiis found essential truths of Islam for themselves
by reliving its central experience. By 12th century, Sufis
began to coalesce into orders (tariqaas: literally ways,
groups) under leaders with their adherents; equivalents of
Christian lay brethern or tertiaries. These orders further
divided into subdivisions, and spread all over Islamic world.
On the peripheries, such as West Africa, Sudan, Indo-Pakistan
and Central Asia, they played a leading role in Muslim
evangelism and remain influential even today. "In their
heyday in the pre-modern period, the orders supplied in the
Sunni world a focus for the emotional aspect of believers'
religious needs, analogous to devotion to the Imams in the
Shi'i one, and acted as a cohesive social force in the
community, specially though not exclusively, among the lower
classes." Prominent orders include Qadiris, of Iraqi
origin but later active in India; Naqshbandis, specially
active in Turkey; Shadhilis, characteristically North African;
Ahmadis, centered on Lower Egypt; recently established
Tijanis, active in North and West Africa; Sanusis; etc. In
Ottoman Turkey, the Bektashis were connected with elite
military force of janissaries and have survived in recent
times, in Albania specially; while Mevelevis, also called the
whirling dervishes, were particularly connected with ruling
classes and were famed for their use of music and gyratory
dancing, recently revived as a tourist
attraction. In the past, extravagances such as
fire-walking, snake-handling, riding over adherents on
horseback, etc., were practiced. (J.R.Hinnells,
Dictionary of Religions, p.313).
How far one can
deviate from the teachings of the Quran and yet claim to be
rightly practicing or righteous Muslim or true seeker of the
Truth or even a Suufii, in that context?!
"…After
living for ten years as a Suufii, Al-Ghazaali found that
the religious experience was the only way of verifying a
reality that lay beyond the reach of the human intellect and
cerebral process..
"Al-Ghazaali eventually
returned to his teaching duties in Baghdad…
"Instead of
being an external, objectified Being whose existence can be
proved rationally, God is an all-enveloping Reality and the
Ultimate existence which can not be perceived as we perceive
the beings that depend upon (Him) and partake of (His)
necessary existence : we have to cultivate a special mode of
seeing."
(Karen Armstrong, A History of God,
pp.219-221). The monastic, and in that sense, mystic approach
is that one should not be tempted by immediate gain and
gratification of world duniyaa, but he should be patient to
strive for better and greater (deferred) reward of aakhirah
(Hereafter). This has very easily led to extreme denial and
asceticism. Some Muslim mystics interpreted duniyaa as prison,
with extreme negative connotations, although the Quran
categorically clarifies that hayaat al-duniyaa (life of this
world) has been so designed that man has to earn for his
hayaat al-aakhirah (life Hereafter) in this world. The test
(trial) of life lies in action and in dealing rightly in this
wordly set up: 67-2. At this point it may be pertinent to
overview the image of Sufism, as understood in the rest of the
world. Dictionary of Religions gives a brief overview:
"The Sufis (wearers of wool, i.e., the coarse garments of
the ascetic) also dervishes (poor men) and, in North Africa,
marabouts, are the mystics of Islam. At the outset they were
influenced by the ascetics of the Eastern Christian churches,
but later they developed mainly within the framework of
orthodox Islam, except for an extravagant, antinomian wing of
the movement in Eastern Persia that may have been influenced
by religious currents from the Indian world. Within these
later Sufis, pantheistic and monist ideas, revolving round the
unity of all existence, are discernible, as in the ideas of
the great Spanish Muslim mystic Ibn Al-Arabi (1165-1240). The
majority of Sufis remained, however, within the bounds of
orthodoxy, regarding the Sufi path, progress through the
stations of worldly renunciation, etc., and the states of
spiritual gifts conferred by God such as nearness to Him, etc,
as the means to real communion with knowledge (ma'rifah) of
God. In this way such ideals as self-annihilation (fanaa),
self-perpetuation with God (baqaa), and even infusion or
indwelling of the Divine Being (hulul) could be achieved.
These could only uneasily be reconciled with orthodox
theology and the external observances of the
Shari'ah.
Sufiism, however,
evolved into distinct orders (Sufi Orders). They had their own
places of congregation and rituals. Sufism has been a great
stimulus to, and a persistent strain in, Islamic literature,
seen for instance in the work of the great Persian poets Rumi
(1207-73) and Hafiz (1325-1390)."
Sufis have remained
at odds with Ulema (Islamic scholars), although a modus
vivendi between these two aspects has also been attempted,
e.g. by Al-Ghazali (1058-1111 C.E.). Sufis have sometimes paid
with their lives, for their views, e.g. Al-Hallaj in 922 C.E.
Therefore phrases like following need to be very carefully and
cautiously analyzed:
"I am the speaking Qur'an"
(Hazrat Ali, may Allah be pleased with him);
"Glory to
me" (Ba-Yazid); "I am the truth" (Mansoor al-Hallaj),
According to Andrae (1987:69), for the early Sufis, 'the world
is thus a concept which , is, in the final analysis,
religiously determined. What the world is, its value or
worthlessness, is determined solely in terms of our
relationship with God'. In this regard, body as the locus for
desire and material gratification is part of world (duniyaa).
Thus body is the pivotal concept of duniyaa. It is regarded as
a product of this world, and worthy of rejection. Only spirit,
the true nature of the self, has potential for human
salvation.
Here we are talking about duniyaa and not earth as nature
and creation of God. For the latter, Sufis extend the Quranic
symphony of the signs of nature in their prose and poetry
also. Andrae cites some lyrical songs of Dhu'l Nuun (d.c.859):
"O God, whenever I listen to the voices of the animals, to the
wind in the tree and the song of the birds, whenever I enjoy
the coolness of shade, listen to the howling storm and raging
thunder, in all this I find a testimony to Thy Goodness."
(Andrae 1987:69)" (Abdulkader Tayob, Islam, A Short
Introduction, p.53)
The believer has, therefore, to
balance between the world known by its conceptual
construction, always potentially ensnaring, and the signs of
God, which are liberating. According to Shah Abdul Latif
Bhitai, in Sur Suhnii, from one aspect, the world is a sign of
God taking the seeker to his beloved (God). From another
perspective, involvement in the world distracts from communion
and meeting Him, the real goal. For proper evaluation of
Islamic conception of the world, we must take into
consideration this perspectival shift between the physical
world and its human appropriation. The world as reality, and
nature is the wonderful creation of God. The signs suggest
true reflection of God. The world as pure human
conceptualization, away from or without God, is dangerous.
In constrast to early Sufis, however, many scholars
have argued for a more moderate approach towards duniyaa.
Extreme asceticism is regarded misunderstanding of true
attitude of Islam towards world and human body. Islam is the
world-affirming religion, and regulates human relations
therein. In fact, the very use of the terms duniyaa and
aakhirah in the Quran, refers to the play between 'now' and
'immediate' on the one hand , and 'later' and 'deferred' on
the other. In verse 93-4, the Prophet (Peace be upon him) is
consoled for his sufferings at the hands of his opponents. He
is told to be patient because: "the deferred (aakhirah) will
be better than the earlier (al-uula)." 93-4
At the
same time world-affirming verses in the Quran (e.g. 28-77)
remind human beings: "not to forget their share of the
duniyaa" 28-77. "And of them there are some, who say: 'Our
Lord! Give us in the world that which is good, and in the
Hereafter that which is good, and save us from the torment of
the Fire." 2-201
Thus, Islam does not ordain that all
world be postponed for the Hereafter.
"In general, the
self-mastery of human beings over the duniyaa was not so much
a complete denial as the 'control' to which Reinhart referred.
Wealth, marriage, children and other pleasures in duniyaa
could well become a distraction, but the test was to exercise
restraint and control.
A well known maxim says: Faith should be in your heart and
the world in your pocket:
You should keep faith, and
be prepared to do without the world. "Thus, the two views may
be placed on a continuum reaching from a distinction between
world and earth to that between world/earth and the
Heareafter." (Abdulkader Tayob, Isla, A Short Introduction,
p.54)
Necessary (Creator-Sustainer) and contingent
(creation)
History shows
that each age appeals to its most impressive technology or
science as a metaphor of cosmos, or even of God. Similarly at
present attempts are made by some theologians and scientists,
both, to explain the revealed statements in the light of
latest available scientific information. First science of
Physics came into existence, with the Big Bang. Some
scientists may like to put the so called idea of Mathematical
Singularity before the idea of the Physical Singularity. All
other sciences came into play, in a sequence to satisfy
unfolding and emerging needs of the universe; one developing
itself and developing into the other - Chemistry, Biology,
Bio-Chemistry, and so on. But "the Reality that we call God
lay outside the realm of sense perception and logical thought,
so science and metaphysics could neither prove nor disprove
the Wujuud (Presence) of Allah." (Karen Armstrong, A History
of God, pp.219-221).
Paul Davies explains the concept
of creation of the universe being contingent which leads to
confirmation of the belief of independent and Necessary
Creator. "Ultimately, it is the assumption that the universe
is both `contingent' and `intelligible' that provides the
motivation for empirical science. For, without the contingency
we would in principle not be able to explain the universe
using logical deduction alone, without ever observing it. And
without the intelligibility there could be no science. `It is
the combination of contingency and intelligibility,' writes
the philosopher Ian Barbour, `which prompts us to search for
new and unexpected forms of rational order.' Barbour points
out that the contingency of the world is fourfold:
First, the laws of physics themselves appear to be
contingent. Second, the cosmological initial
conditions could have been otherwise. Third, we
know from quantumn mechanics that `God plays dice'- i.e. there
is a fundamental statistical element in nature..
Finally, there is the fact that the universe exists.
"After all, however comprehensive our theories of the
universe may be, there is no obligation for the world actually
to instantiate that theory. This last point has been vividly
expressed by Stephen Hawking: `Why does the universe go to all
the bother of existing?', he asks. `What is that
breathes fire into the equations and makes a universe for them
to describe?"
"..There is also a fifth
type of contingency, which is to be found in the
`higher-level' laws associated with the organizational
properties of complex systems. Mendel's laws of genetics,..
though perfectly consistent with the underlying laws of
physics, could not be derived solely from the laws of physics.
Likewise, the various laws and regularities found in chaotic
systems, or in self-organizing systems, depend not only on the
laws of physics, but also on the specific nature of the
systems concerned. In many cases the precise form of the
patterns of behaviour adopted by these systems depends upon
some `accidental' microscopic fluctuation, and must therefore
be considered as undetermined in advance. These higher-level
laws and regularities thus possess important
contingent features over and above the usual laws of
physics.
"The great mystery about contingency is not
so much that the world could have been otherwise, but it is
contingently `ordered'. This is most forcefully apparent in
the biological realm, where terrestrial organisms are clearly
contingent in their particular forms (they could so easily
have been different), where there is a conspicuous and
pervasive order in the biosphere. If objects and events in the
world were merely haphazard and arranged in no specially
significant way, their `particular' arrangement would still be
mysterious. But the fact that the contingent features of the
world are also ordered or patterned is surely deeply
meaningful. "Another highly relevant feature of the world's
ordered contingency concerns the `nature of that order', which
is such as to bestow a rational unity on the cosmos.. `It
is this combination of contingence, rationality, freedom and
stability of the universe,' writes Torrance, `which gives
it its remarkable character, and which makes scientific
exploration of the universe not only possible for us but
incumbent upon us…It is through relying on the
indissoluble bond between contingence and order in the
universe that natural science has come to operate with the
distinctive interconnection between experiment and theory
which has characterized our greatest advances in knowledge of
the physical world." (Shahzado Shaikh, The Gateway to the
Quran, pp.174-175)
The proofs of God's Presence, and
those of His Power, and Attributes, as exhibited in nature,
are known as Zaahir-ul Mumkinaat: Religious scholars explain
His Independent Wujuud (Presence) and dependant existence of
His creation in different ways:
Waajib-ul Wujuud: The
Necessary Presence - Only God is the Necessary Presence,
Absolute Presence or Absolute Reality Mumkin-ul Wujuud:
possible existence: relative existence or contingent reality
Mumtani-ul Wujuud: impossible existence, e.g., an
associate with God
From Surah Ikhlaas (Surah 112),
first two levels of existence can be explained. Once these two
levels are understood, the third one then becomes easier to
understand. For Absolute Reality Surah Ikhlaas uses unique and
specific terminology: Huwa, Allah, Ahad, and As-Samad.
Ontology deals with the knowledge of Absolute Reality.
Contingent (creation or existence) is the subject of study of
Cosmology. The contingent reality of space-time is limited and
controlled, in which everything has a specific place and
position making arrangement and organization possible. The
dependent creation has been created in pairs: azwaaj (51-49).
Therefore contingent is not comparable with the Only and the
One, Necessary, in any sense, and as such it does not qualify
to be associated with the latter.
Sufi view of
Necessary and Contingent
Sufis
believe that Allah is Necessary for all existence, knowledge,
power, matter, energy, intention, intuition, hearing, speech,
all faculties and forms of life. Scientists explain this as
contingent existence in a system of unified law, dependent on
the Necessary. Tafsir-e-Mazhari has quoted verses 22-62 and
28-88, which provide some explanation in this
regard.
Allah is Unique (Ahad) in every Attribute. When
we say He Knows everything, His Knowledge is not like that of
any creature or any created thing. Allah knows, everything
seen and unseen, in His Omni-Presence, as ever all
Informed-Scientist. He knows everything about everything,
being Himself the Creator-Sustainer of all. Only Allah knows
better, everything (Wallaahu A'alamu).
Therefore those who know truth do not interpret "Laa-ilaaha
illallaahu": (There is no god, except Allah) as "Laa ma'buud
illallaahu': (There is no one worthy of worship-obedience,
except Allah), but they interpret it as 'Laa maujuudu
illallaahu": (There is no existence-presence, save Allah).
(Tafsir-e-Mazhari, Vol-11 & 12, p. 379-380).
From above statements, in simple words, it follows
that there is no existence without His Presence.
"Furthermore, O Arjuna! I am the generating seed of
all existence. There is no being - moving or nonmoving - that
can exist without Me.".. (A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada,
The Opulence of the Absolute, Bhagavad-Gita as it is, p. 385)
"..There is not a moving creature, but He (Allah) has
grasp of its forelock.." 11-56
"And no moving creature
is there on earth, but its sustenance depends on Allah. And He
knows its dwelling place and its deposit. All is in a clear
Book." (Al-Lauh-al-Mahfuuz: The Hard Disc) 11-6 Also 18-39 and
36-83.
He comprehends all existence as well as nature
of unseen-hidden. He is the Only One Who can create ex nihilo
and also blot out existence.
Correction of Sufi
Views on Presence and Existence
Here His Presence must be
differentiated from other existence as it should be
differentiated both from pantheism and panentheism. Such
concepts of oneness of existence (wahdat-al-wujuud) need to be
carefully examined. In pantheism it is conjectured that whole
of reality is divine (Laa wujuudu illallaahu: There is no
existence except He). In panentheism it is conjectured that
God includes and permeates, but is not exhausted by all that
is known in sense-experience. In this connection discussions
about Necessary and contingent (creation) by Paul Davies in
his book The Mind of God, and also interpretation and
explanation of Surah Ikhlaas (112) in Tafsir-e-Mazhari (Vols.
11-12, pp.377-382), provide some interesting explanations. It
is extremely essential to be careful to differentiate
conjecture and adventure in conceptualization about oneness or
unity of existence of created physical things from monotheism,
as clarified in the Quran:
"And there are among them
illiterate, who know not the Book, but they trust upon false
desires, and they do nothing but conjecture." 2-78
Avoiding Conjecture
One should avoid unnecessary conceptualization, and be
careful about such discourses and discussions that get
confused by conjecture, leading to idle argument rather than
active implementation of good of the faith for benefit of
mankind. Consequently such an idle mind may be cast into so
called mystic mould, leaving man and his society into a state
of passive existence. Therefore it is better to avoid
hair-splitting subtleties and unnecessary semantics.
Studies show that innumerable strands of mystic
concepts ultimately proved to be too idealized, ineffable and
narrowly individualistic. When stretched onto enlarged scale
of Islamic society, they blurred the cross cutting dynamic
concept of universal Islam into personal cult, shrouded in
myth, mystery, and miracle. All other factors responsible for
fall of nations played their part, and ultimately Muslims lost
their cutting edge in conquests. They closed eyes to the
theophany in physical phenomena and cosmos. They abandoned
pursuit of science, observation and advancement through
experimentation. They 'hardened their hearts' through schism
and groupings, closing all possibilities of ijmaa and ijtihad
guided by interpretation and reasoning in the Quran itself.
Instead, they left reading and teaching of the Quran and the
Sunnah as a professional pursuit for livelihood and
advancement of interests of individuals and groups. They
adopted and adhered to their fatwaas (verdicts) as an
authority and a final word on the Quran and the Sunnah,
without any need to refer to or to know the source in
original. As different classes and schools of thought, they
initially excelled in Falsafaa and Ilm-ul Kalaam, mainly
influenced by Greek philosophy. Thus the freshly sprouting
sapling of public administration, rooted into justice and
human rights, planted in Madina, was routed out, when they
adopted corrupt practices of governance after coming into
contact with Roman Empire. Persian culture and civilization
influenced and admixtured equally as did Indian mysticism and
mythology.
It is high time that Muslim Ummah, in the
words of Iqbal, embarks upon search for a new order, with a
fresh mind and a pure heart; a mind that is open to creative
thinking and a heart that accepts new ideas; i.e., ijtihad.
According to Dr Hamid Ullah, ijtihad is the duty
of every Muslim. But ijtihad is possible only if creative
thinking becomes essential part of our being.
The Term Huwa Stands For Allah
Coming back to the main topic, it is
clear that the term Huwa has many connotations and
explanations in the background of the revelation and spirit of
Surah Ikhlaas. Syed Muhammad Rafai Arab, in his
'Tafsir-e-Rafai', (p.730), says that Huwa is a noun that
refers to the Other One, of which existence is sure, though
unseen-hidden. Polytheists used the term haadhaa (this) in
pointation to a thing which could be perceived with five
senses. So it was in reply and in admonition to them as they
used to point to idols placed before them, e.g., 'Haadhihii
ilaahunaa' (These are our gods). They used to say that as
their gods were displayed before them, Muhammad (Peace be upon
him) should also point in the same manner that they could see
Him in a direction, in a place and position.
Some
commentators believe that the word Huwa stands for the High
Exalted Name of God (Al Ism-ul A'zam), which Muslim scholars
say is only known to God. But it is also held that either
Al-Hayyu, or Al-Qayyuum is the Ismul A'azam. There is another
tradition, from which it appears that the Great Name may be
either Al-Ahad (the One) or As-Samad (the Eternal). According
to some other Traditions and some scholars, Allah is the
Greatest Name or the High Exalted Name--- Al-Ism al-A'azam.
(Thomas Patrick Hughes, A Dictionary of Islam, p.181). It has
been reported that the Prophet (Peace be upon him) saw a man
praying and supplicating, saying: "O Allah! Verily, I ask you,
by my testifying that there is no god worthy of worship except
You. You are the One, the Self-Sufficient Sustainer of all,
Who does not give birth, nor were You born, and there is none
comparable to You."
The Prophet (Peace be upon
him) said: "By He in Whose Hand is my soul, verily he has
asked Him by His Greatest Name. It is His Name that if He is
asked by it, He will give, and if He is called upon by it, He
will answer." (An-Nasai in Al-Kubra, Tuhfat Al-Ashraf 2-90)
Some scholars, like Talikani, say that Huwa itself is
complete in all senses: a complete word and a sentence. It is
comprehensive in itself. Huwa has been used with Great Glory
in many verses of the Holy Quran (e.g. 2-255), and also in
many Traditions. Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) gives his
reflections as: "Yaa Huwa, (O He!) man laa ya'lam maa Huwa,
(Whom no one knows what He is) wa laa kaifa Huwa, wa laa aina
Huwa, (and neither, where He is) wa laa haitha Huwa, (and nor,
ever-where He is) illaa Huwa." (Except that He is)
Prof. Karar Hussain has quoted Tabatabai, from
Al-Mizan that Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) said that he
had learnt a formulation, with which he overcame his enemies
in all his encounters:
"Yaa Huwa (O He!) Yaa man laa
Huwa illaa Huwa" (O He, there is no he, except He) When Ali
(may Allah be pleased with him) told this, the Prophet (Peace
be upon him), is reported to have said that he had learnt
Ism-al A'azam (The Great Name of Allah). [Prof. Karar Hussain,
(Quran jo Mutaa-li-o, (Study of Quran, pp.74-75] Prof Karar
Hussain says that this introduction must have influenced the
explanation given above by Talikani.
As already
discussed, it is not a pointation which makes the object
pointed at as limited; since Allah is not limited. It is
only to save from nullification that Allah has explained
Himself with certain Names and Attributes, so that people can
understand Him, otherwise He is High Exalted above limitations
of words and their explanations.
Surah
Al-Ikhlaas with all frankness and gracious style of expression
moves forward to assert that the Personality, Who has just
been introduced as Huwa is Allah, the Only One Alone to Whom
worship is due. With candid introduction, the concept has been
cleared about the same One Being, Whom they already knew by
the Name of Allah. Arabs were already familiar with this Name,
Allah. They did not apply this Name to any of their gods. This
Name was applied for the Creator of universe and everything,
since earlier times. For idols, as gods, they applied the term
'ilaah'. They called Ka'bah as 'Bait-Allah' and not as
'Bait-ilaah'. Familiarity of Arabs with this terminology is
quite clear in lexicography, philology and linguistics of
Arabic and their history, lore and literature.
"If you
ask them, who created them, they will surely say, 'Allah'.
43-87 Also see 29-61 to 63, 23-84 to 89, 10-22, 23 & 31,
17-67, and compare verses 43-87 and 34-24.
Continuity of Dialogue and Conclusion
The Quran has the unique style
of dialogue and the way of communication. It discusses
subjects frankly; even puts questions to initiate dialogue and
answers queries to satisfy and put minds at ease. In Surah
Ikhlaas also it goes on to introduce with all aptness, for
taking the discussion to its logical conclusion. Starting with
Huwa, underlines continuity of the topic under discussion and
response to the questions which were already in circulation.
Therefore, for the study of this Surah, background to
revelation of this Surah has to be fully kept in view. 'He is
Allah'(112-1): when this was said in reply to questions of
polytheists, it was to remind and clarify to them that He is
the Same One Allah Whom they already knew and invoked in times
of fear, need and emergency, and it is about Him that they had
been raising silly questions.
There are other
subtleties also, bordering on admonition for those who were
indulging into idiotic debate and going too far in their
foolishness in conceptualizing God within their own
dimensional design, demands and desires. They were told that
about Whom you are putting silly and stupid questions, He is
Allah, the Most-High, so beware!
|